Giggs: Money is making teenage players richer - not better
I signed my first professional contract at Manchester United on my 17th birthday, Nov 29, 1990, and with the strike of a pen went from my apprentice wages of £29.50 a week, plus £10 expenses, to the rather more considerable sum of £170 per week, plus first team bonuses.
It would not be until the following March that I made my first team debut but when I sat in Sir Alex Ferguson’s office that morning it was not really the money that was on my mind but another issue.
As an apprentice I had to go to Stretford College every Thursday and I did not much enjoy it. Did I still have to go? “You’re a pro now,” Sir Alex said. “It’s up to you.”
That Thursday I was in the canteen queuing up for some food at the Cliff training ground when I felt a tap on my shoulder. It was Eric Harrison, our fearsome youth team coach.
“What are you doing here?” he asked. I tried to explain to him that I was a pro now and that I no longer had to go to college. It would be fair to say Eric did not see it the same way. He told me very firmly to put my plate down, get out the building and get on the No 52 bus to college.
I can still remember walking out with my stomach empty and going into college midway through a class. I only tell the story now because the way in which we develop academy boys in the modern age, as well as the money on offer for the best, and the trade in teenagers, has changed the game beyond recognition.
I am well aware that any former player talking about youngsters today can sound bitter. I am not.
My issue is this: I think the money is helping teenage footballers get richer, I do not think it is helping them become better footballers. The skill levels of young players are still there. I am not sure about the desire. When I was growing up I saw boys with much less talent make careers for themselves through sheer will-power. There were strong personalities in every team.
One of my clear memories as a young teenager was getting the bus to a Salford boys’ trial. Only one problem: it was the wrong bus. I panicked that I would be late. Nowadays boys are taken everywhere by the clubs. The issues that most normal teenagers face - the problem solving, the out-of-the-comfort-zone moments – it all helps them develop. That maturity also counts for a lot on the pitch.
There are exceptions. When I would talk to Marcus Rashford I could see in his eyes that he listened. He wanted to improve. His mentality did not change when he broke into the first team under Louis van Gaal. When I did the same, it was still a long time until I was allowed to change in the first team dressing room. You had to earn that right.
On that first pro deal, I was earning £170 a week but there was also £300 a point for any game I played in. On top of that there were big bonuses for winning trophies: £10,000 for the League Cup, £20,000 for the FA Cup, £25,000 for the league title. You won trophies because you wanted to be a successful footballer but the money was good too, and in those days it was very incentive driven.
The biggest players in the first United team I played in were on £3,000 to £4,000-a-week. When Eric Cantona signed a contract of £10,000-a-week it felt like an amazing amount of money. Now there is nothing stopping first-time professionals being able to drive the same cars and buy the same clothes as the senior players. I have seen boys promoted into the first team dressing room who would never have been allowed in during my days as a young pro.
I have also seen the effect of a 17-year-old boy become the main breadwinner in the family when he signs his first deal and his parents give up their jobs. That’s a lot of pressure on a teenage boy who has not yet started growing and is by no means certain to be a top professional.
On top of my first pro wages, I was given £40 digs money to be given to my landlady, which in my case was my mum. I don’t think I have ever cancelled the standing order to this day.
The club recommended me an accountant who is still my accountant 27 years on. I would go to the NatWest branch that used to be over the road from Old Trafford, by the Liverpool Warehousing building, where I would get my wages each week after finishing my apprentice’s jobs - including working in the club shop.
I know it sounds like a different era. And, yes, even in those days there were some young players who were paid more than others. The change now is that the basic amounts are so enormous that it must be hard for these players not to get carried away. How can you concentrate on making it as a top player, when your wages suggest you already have?
I am afraid to say that despite Stretford College’s best efforts I was not a great student. I wonder to this day whether Sir Alex and Eric set me up that Thursday as a means of reminding me that even though I was a professional at Manchester United there was still a long way to go. Whatever the reason it was a moment I never forgot, which I suppose was the intention.
Only the very best coaches know how to strike that balance between encouragement and discipline, and United were very good at it - although I have to say it is a lot easier when the teenager in question is on a weekly wage of £170 rather than £17,000.
More from Ryan Giggs:
- Where the Arsenal vs Man City FA Cup semi-final will be won and lost
- Where the Chelsea vs Spurs FA Cup semi-final will be won and lost
- Ryan Giggs's Premier League team of the season so far: Who makes the cut?
- Manchester United must turn fixture pile-up to their advantage - just like Ferguson did
- Money is making teenage players richer - not better
- Ross Barkley is no longer a kid - his excellence needs to become the norm
- Why referees must show the human touch
- Archery, the right suit and teamwork: how to win a cup final
- Arsenal can still thrive – even if Arsene Wenger departs
- I wish Manchester United had signed N'Golo Kante
- The secret to closing out a Premier League title race
- Danny Rose has all the qualities of my old Man Utd mate Patrice Evra
- Why Manchester City's struggles are no surprise
- Zlatan Ibrahimovic has the same aura as Eric Cantona - and is just as lethal
- The night Antonio Conte provoked me into confronting Sir Alex Ferguson - it didn't end well
- Why old-school defending is a dying art
- Mauricio Pochettino has given Spurs a steel they used to lack
- Marcus Rashford can be Manchester United's next No. 9
- The day Pep Guardiola almost forced me to quit football
- Why Man Utd vs Arsenal was my ultimate grudge match
- How going long can beat Jurgen Klopp's gegenpress
- Why I fear this could be Liverpool's year in the Premier League title race
- I have discovered that even Arsenal players can be great company!
- Sir Alex Ferguson left a huge void at Manchester United but decline was not inevitable